The short answer
Google My Maps is a consumer map-sharing tool that happens to draw polygons. Map Zone Picker is a boundary-drawing tool that happens to run in a browser. If your work is "mark the five store locations and share them," stay with Google My Maps. If your work is "keeping three candidate franchise territories, comparing their area and sending the approved one to a lawyer as GeoJSON," that second workflow is the one Google My Maps does not cover — and it is the whole product here.
Side by side
| Capability | Google My Maps | Map Zone Picker |
|---|---|---|
| Draw polygons on a map | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Keep multiple named versions of the same boundary | — No — one map, layers inside it | ✓ Yes — scenarios, nothing overwritten |
| Show area & perimeter while drawing | — Not in the editor | ✓ Yes — on preview, before saving |
| Export the boundary as GeoJSON / KML / CSV | KML export; CSV of pins, not polygons | ✓ All three, per zone and per scenario |
| Collaborative editing with Google sharing | ✓ Yes | — No — export the file instead |
| Renders inside Google Maps on mobile | ✓ Yes | — No — its own basemap styles |
| Spreadsheet import with address geocoding | ✓ Yes | — No — coordinates in, not addresses |
| Basemap | Google Maps layers | OpenStreetMap (3 styles) |
| Requires an account to draw | Google account | ✓ No — account only for cloud save |
The versioning gap, in practice
A territory decision is rarely one shape. You sketch a split that balances store count, then a second that balances drive time, then a third because finance wants the county line respected. In Google My Maps each option becomes another layer — or another whole map — and the comparison happens in screenshots.
In Map Zone Picker each option is a named scenario with its own zones. Switching costs one click and overwrites nothing, so the option you rejected in March is still there in September, exactly as it was drawn. That record is what turns "I think we agreed on the wider one" into a file you can open.
The same gap applies to measurement. Google My Maps draws the shape but does not report area or perimeter while you edit, so the numbers come later — by hand, in Google Earth or QGIS. Here the area and perimeter appear on preview, while the boundary is still negotiable.
What Google My Maps genuinely does better
- Collaboration. Share a map like a Google Doc and edit together. Map Zone Picker has no simultaneous editing — the exchange format is a file.
- Google ecosystem rendering. Your layers open in the Google Maps app on anyone's phone. If the audience is "everyone on the team, zero instructions," that reach matters.
- Address import. Paste a spreadsheet of place names and Google geocodes them to pins. Map Zone Picker takes coordinates, not addresses — it will not guess where "Springfield" is.
- Photos and rich pins. Attach images and descriptions to places. This is a boundaries tool; there is nowhere to hang a photo.
None of these are oversights — the two tools are aimed at different jobs. The comparison only matters when the job is boundaries.
Moving an existing boundary over
If a territory already lives in Google My Maps, export the layer as KML. The coordinates in that file are standard WGS84 — paste the vertex list into Map Zone Picker's coordinate points, connect them in order, and the zone rebuilds there. Drawing styles, photos and pinned places do not transfer; the geometry does.
From there the workflow changes: the boundary becomes a scenario you can duplicate, measure, and export as GeoJSON, KML or CSV — the formats QGIS, ArcGIS and Google Earth already open. If you would rather start from a clean boundary than migrate one, the step-by-step zone drawing walkthrough starts from the first corner.
The verdict
Keep Google My Maps for what it is good at: shared pin maps inside the Google ecosystem. Use Map Zone Picker when the deliverable is a boundary — when options need to be versioned, measured and exported as files that a lawyer, a GIS contractor or an ops team can actually open. One workflow, one browser tab, free to start.
Honest limitation: Map Zone Picker does not geocode addresses, render inside Google Maps, or support collaborative editing. If any of those is the core need, this is not the right tool for it.